The Digg Widget, diggthis.js, and Useless Traffic

SMS Text

There is no denying, by whatever measure you use, that Digg gets a lot of inbound traffic and as a result, generate a lot of outbound traffic for the site’s that get showcased on its homepage. But if you look close enough, a lot of Digg’s incoming traffic is actually absolutely useless.
Digg, Netscape, and Reddit, all offer ways to integrate their sites with yours using buttons. But what is different about Digg when compared to the other two sites in terms of integration is that if you place a ‘Digg This’ on your blog, every time a visitor Diggs a story from your site, the widget automatically force-redirects the visitor from your site to the Digg page for that particular submission. In contrast, if you Netscape-vote or Reddit-vote for a story while on a blog using an integrated widget, these widgets don’t force-redirect you to the social sites’ pages for that story.
From my understanding, the culprit is the diggthis.js part of the submission widget script (which was also cited as a possible reason why Compete thinks that Digg has the same traffic as Facebook). This traffic going to Digg, however, is largely useless because you have already read the article on the blog and you’re highly likely to close the page anyway.
The argument can be made for both sides. While content producers want traffic from socially driven sites, at the same time they don’t want users leaving their sites. And from Digg’s perspective, why shouldn’t they make you come to their site, it shouldn’t be a one-sided relationship, should it? However, if you’re going to try and justify this by arguing that the user-generated commentary on socially driven sites is worth the visit, I beg to differ.

Download: Social Media Strategy
Where the rubber meets the road: A look at SEJ's own social media strategy.