We’ve all been there.
After months of hard work, you finally launch a new product or service and, instead of just praise, your business gets the dreaded negative review.
Your mind starts racing.
You ask yourself, “How bad will this be for my SEO?”
Panic starts to set in.
Will your negative review suck all of the life and money out of your business, leaving you with nothing to show for all the hard work you’ve put into building up your brand?
It isn’t the end of the world.
One or two negative reviews don’t have the power to torpedo your business.
While we all want positive reviews, the bad ones aren’t as bad as you think.
Negative reviews can actually help search engine rankings.
Let me explain why.
Negative Reviews Increase the Overall Number of Reviews
When people search for a local business, Google returns several results that show how many stars each one has.
But have you ever noticed that Google also shows how many reviews the business has overall?
The total number of reviews increases the social proof for your business and contributes to localized search ranking factors.
Of course, no one knows exactly how much reviews help SEO.
The key point is that you want to have a diverse array of opinions, including a few negative reviews, to help search engines verify the legitimacy of your business.
A Harvard Business School study on restaurant demand showed that consumers don’t actually read all the available information on local businesses (no surprise there).
Also, and more importantly, the study showed that the total number of reviews affected the way consumers would respond to a restaurant’s average rating.
In other words, consumers rely on mental shortcuts when making decisions.
If your site has 100 reviews, or even just 25, very few people are actually going to read every last one.
Consumers just want to know that your business has an engaged following before they make a purchase decision.
What if you’re running an ecommerce business? Can negative reviews hurt your SEO in that case?
The people behind search engines like Google understand that no one is perfect.
Google’s internal SEO guidelines instruct website reviewers to keep in mind that even some of the best sites get bad reviews.
While negative reviews shouldn’t be ignored, you can rest assured a few of them won’t sink your reputation.
In fact, the opposite is true.
Negative Reviews Actually Increase Your Credibility
When consumers see nothing but positive reviews, they tend to get suspicious.
The Journal of Vacation Marketing found that consumers tend to think negative reviews have more credibility than a positive review.
Research from Harvard Business School found that moderately positive reviews are oftentimes more persuasive than excessively positive reviews.
To put it another way: those unbelievably happy customers are a little too unbelievable and their reviews tend to generate skepticism.
Research suggests that consumers like to see a mix of good, moderate, and bad reviews when trying to determine if a business is trustworthy.
This applies whether you’re a local bakery or an ecommerce store with a global reach.
If a variety of reviews leads to greater credibility, it stands to reason that consumers will be more willing to spend time on your website, thereby increasing your search engine rankings in the long run.
Time on page (the length of time spent on an individual page) and session duration (the overall length of time spent on a site) are both critical measures when you’re aiming to improve SEO.
Negative Reviews Are an Opportunity to Build Relationships with Customers
Another benefit of getting negative reviews is that you’re also getting feedback about your business that you can take action on.
If you have a customer service problem (or another type of problem), you’ll know what’s going on and you can correct the problem.
When your business responds appropriately to negative reviews, it shows that you value customer feedback and you’re willing to take corrective action.
Knowing that they’ll be taken care of if anything goes wrong helps customers feel more comfortable making a decision to buy from your business.
It also helps with local SEO.
A support page for Google My Business instructs businesspeople to “manage and respond to reviews.”
Google isn’t hiding the fact that reviews contribute to local search rankings so it’s safe to assume the same holds true for the websites of larger businesses.
Here’s the key takeaway on this point: negative reviews give businesses a chance to show that they’re willing and able to manage their online reputation by responding appropriately to negative reviews – an important quality that factors into search rankings.
Negative Reviews Provide a More Accurate Picture of Your Business
When expectations aren’t met, customers experience disappointment — one of the main reasons people complain.
In a study of 1.3 million reviews we conducted at Yotpo (the company I work for), words conveying “disappointment” appeared more than 20,000 times.
Coming in a distant second with 7,500 mentions was the word “bad.”
Clearly, disappointment matters. But there is an upside.
Negative reviews expressing disappointment help potential customers understand more clearly what your company does — and does not — offer.
These types of reviews also help your business demonstrate how it handles customer disappointment.
Having negative reviews available online helps ensure that when customers choose to buy, they’re more likely to know in advance what they’re getting, potentially decreasing returns as well as the sheer number of disappointed customers in the long run.
A few negative reviews provide a more balanced look at your products and services, increasing the credibility and trustworthiness of your business.
Looking at a range of reviews from very positive to not-so-great can reassure customers that your website is a good place to spend time — and as we’ve already discussed, the overall length of time that consumers spend on your site improves your search rankings.
Negative Reviews Can Drive Your SEO & Content Marketing
If you mine the data inside each and every negative comment, you could help to amend and target your SEO strategies.
Negative reviews can help you better understand your audience. As you read, ask yourself:
- What did this consumer want that we aren’t delivering?
- What was this consumer promised that we didn’t match?
- What questions does this consumer have about our products or our company?
- What sorts of searches would lead another consumer to this content?
You could create a series of blog posts or social media posts that address every one of these issues.
For example, if the complaint concerns time from order to plate, you could write up posts about your artisan approach to food, highlighting the fact that your orders are made on demand.
You’ll understand your audience better, and you might get a new audience that will be less likely to complain.
Embrace the Negative
Hopefully you now see that bad reviews have a good side.
These seemingly disappointing reviews can actually help you reach your business goals.
Negative reviews help you show that your business is responsive, trustworthy, and real.
As long as you handle it properly, you might get a consumer that stays with you for life.
The more happy customers you have, the easier your marketing and SEO becomes because you’ll have less mistakes to deal with.
So the next time you get a negative review, don’t see it as a failure but a massive opportunity to build your brand and credibility.
Because, as long as you run a really good business that people love, the positive reviews will outweigh the negative ones.
More Local SEO Resources:
- Where & How to Get the Right Reviews for Your Business
- 23 Facts You Should Know About Online Reviews
- Can Negative Brand Mentions Hurt Your Google Rankings?
Subscribe to SEJ
Get our weekly newsletter from SEJ's Founder Loren Baker about the latest news in the industry!