Why Building an Audience is so Hard (And Why I’m Still Trying)

SMS Text
Why Building an Audience is so Hard (And Why I’m Still Trying)

It’s easy to feel like you can grow a loyal audience in no time using the latest growth hacks or Twitter and Facebook tricks. But the truth is, it’s not that simple.

Growing an audience is hard.

You have to have talent. You have to put in a lot of work. And there’s no 1–2–3 solution.

In this post, I’m happy to share some of our experiences from building an audience at Buffer alongside six key ingredients to successfully building an audience.

Let’s get started!

Why it’s Difficult to Build an Audience (And Why There’s No Shortcut)

“Nothing in the world is worth having or worth doing unless it means effort, pain, difficulty… I have never in my life envied a human being who led an easy life. I have envied a great many people who led difficult lives and led them well.” ― Theodore Roosevelt

It is no secret that we live in an age of information overload. Yet many of us are in search of a larger audience. More readers on our blog. A bigger following across social media. A group of people who read, engage with and amplify everything we share.

The problem is, we live in an attention economy. Everyone is vying for consumer attention, and there’s only so much to go around.

Attention is Limited

We all have 24 hours in a day. There’s nothing we can do to change that.

Each day on Facebook alone we are potentially exposed to 1,500 pieces of content. When you add in Tweets, Snapchats, Instagram posts and all the other content we’re exposed to daily, it’s easy to see why it can be so hard to break through as a content creator.

This graphic from Moz shows how content fatigue could start happening very soon.

It Takes a Lot of Swings

Each day we have a tiny window to grab people’s attention and make an impact with our content. And many of us are in search of that one, elusive thing that’ll get us rolling on the path to success. But that’s not how it works.

Think of yourself as a Major League Baseball player, for every home run, for every cheer from the crowd, there are thousands of practice swings and plenty of strikeouts. Content is no different. You need to step up to the plate and bring your best every day if you want to be a success.

There’s no shortcut to building an audience. It’s a long, winding road. And it takes a number of elements to succeed. Below I’d love to share some of the key ingredients to building at audience.

The 6 Essential Ingredients to Build an Audience Successfully

1. Look for What’s Next

The world is moving fast, and opportunities are arising everywhere. New platforms and new trends breed new opportunity. And for early adopters a unique chance to build an audience as Gary Vaynerchuk explains on Medium:

If you play close attention to the people who popped on Vine, or the people who popped in the early days of Snapchat, or Instagram, they all happened to be the Christopher Columbus of their platforms. They were early. So as those platforms took off, they developed disproportionate amounts of followers as new users joined and found them.

First Mover Advantage

A study from Harvard Business Review found that companies identified as believing strongly in the benefits of adopting new technologies receive a “first-mover advantage” — and are more likely to lead in both revenue growth and market position than their peers.

The same theory applies to new social platforms too. As an early adopter, you can gain first mover advantage and, as Gary Vaynerchuk said, you have the chance to become “the Christopher Columbus” of that platform.

By focusing on what’s next and experimenting with new platforms and technologies, you have an opportunity to jump ahead of the competition and build an audience before the platform is too crowded.

Hone Your Skills

Shaun McBride, better known as Shonduras online, is one of Snapchat’s first homegrown celebrities, and brands are spending upwards of $30,000 for advertising deals with him and other Snapchat stars.

Before Snapchat, Shonduras honed his skills as an artist. Snapchat merely provided a platform for him to share his skills with the world.

Why Building an Audience is Hard | Search Engine Journal

The biggest opportunities ahead probably aren’t on Facebook, Twitter, or YouTube but on platforms we don’t even know about yet. That doesn’t mean you can’t start preparing for these opportunities, though:

  • If you want to be an influential writer, practice writing: on your blog, on Medium, on Twitter, or anywhere you can scribble down a few words.
  • If you love to create video, experiment with Vine, YouTube, Snapchat, and Beme.

Whatever your skill set, find new ways to be creative. Hone your talents. And then when the next big platform launches, jump on it and set the trends there.

2. Have a Voice

Everything has been said before, but it’s never been said by you. Your point of view is what makes you interesting. — Jory MacKay

For periods in my writing life, I’ve relied on content that is ‘good enough’, content that gets a point across. That ticks a box. But doesn’t reflect me or my personal beliefs.

On reflection, this doesn’t feel the way to break through and build an audience. Great content should make you feel vulnerable and a little discomfort upon publishing.

As Jory MacKay points out over at Crew, when you approach a new subject, ask yourself ‘how can I cover this in a way that only I can?’  Your voice is what will make you stand out from the crowd.

Saying the same things as everyone else, in the same style will only add to the noise. And you’ll get lost in the endless sea of content published every day.

This graphic from Sean McCabe illustrates how to find your unique voice perfectly.

3. Do Things Differently

At Buffer, we’re super lucky to be well-known for our content. But our rise wasn’t an overnight success — and certainly didn’t come easy.

It took some trial and error. And a few years back we found a recipe that started to pay off.

From day 1, we have invested in content marketing at Buffer. Leo kicked things off on the blog back in 2011 and since then we’ve been through quite a few evolutions and tried many different tactics to build our audience.

Here’s a quick at the development of our content over time:

  1. Twitter tips: January 2011 – October 2011
  2. Pivot to social media tips: November 2011 – June 2012
  3. Pivot to lifehacks, writing, customer happiness, and business: June 2012 — March 2014
  4. Pivot to social media marketing and content tips: March 2014 to now

And a fun gif showing how the blog design has changed:

Why Building an Audience is Hard | Search Engine Journal

If you check back through our first posts, they contain great content but they weren’t distinguishable from other social media blogs out there.

At this stage – when we weren’t getting hundreds of thousands or millions of views per month – we could’ve decided to focus elsewhere. Instead, we tried to do things differently and create our Buffer style of content.

We pivoted from Twitter tips to broader social media tips. And in June 2012 we pivoted again. We began focusing on in-depth, well-researched posts that broke down potentially complex subjects into clear, understandable, and highly shareable content. Things started to take off after this pivot.

Here’s an early example of one of these posts:

Why Building an Audience is Hard | Search Engine Journal

After some success with this style of post, the biggest jump in traffic came when Belle Beth Cooper joined the Buffer team, and we doubled down on producing unique content.

If it wasn’t for our early experiments, we may never have discovered the potential of this type of content and may never have unlocked all of the traffic (and conversions!) we see today.

You Need to Keep Evolving

Leo and Belle were so great at discovering the potential of in-depth content. Another shift for us occurred a year or so ago when we came to focus social media marketing and content tips – paying particular attention to the visuals and images within our articles.

More recently, Kevan shared that our social referral traffic has nearly halved over the past year. This post sparked a ton of discussion about our content both internally and externally.

The below Tweets from Rand Fishkin especially resonated with our team:

Why Building an Audience is Hard | Search Engine Journal

This debate gave us a chance to reflect and re-evaluate our content. It also inspired Leo to share our marketing manifesto. Since then, we’ve re-focused and started experimenting again. As Kevan explains: our blog is our greatest marketing asset. And we just keep changing it.

Only time will tell if our new experiments will pay off. However, one thing is for sure – the hard work from the past years will go to waste if we don’t continue to push ourselves and figure out how to continually keep evolving our content.

4. Hard Work

I’ve learned from experience that if you work harder at it, and apply more energy and time to it, and more consistency, you get a better result. It comes from the work. — Louis C.K.

Success comes from the work that noone sees.

If you want to build an audience you need to put in a lot of hard work.

Let’s take Seth Godin, for example.

Before he was a best-selling author and marketing thought leader he was Seth Godin, just another blogger.

Godin’s blog has posts going back to 2002. But, as Ailian Gan points out on her blog, it’s around 2006 where Seth Godin hits his stride and starts to sound like the Seth of today. That’s four years of finding his voice and honing his skills.

Another example is Nils Wagner, the man behind Hoopmixtape. Hoopmixtape’s website and YouTube channel receive millions and millions of views each month. What’s not clear is the work that goes on to ensure it stays that way.

Sam Laird explains over at The Classical:

To stay on top, Wagner travels tens of thousands of miles yearly to gather footage of elite prospects, sometimes driving thirty hours straight and living out of his car for weeks at a stretch.

Building an audience is hard work. And you’ll need to put in the hours if you want to succeed.

5. Focus on Quality

In our Buffer marketing manifesto Leo explains:

Sometimes we think that just putting out a consistent number of things will just create some outliers that’ll help us win. Heck, I even believed this for a long time and advised people to just focus on quantity. I don’t think that’s true anymore. Yes, we need to output things at high quantity, but we need to treat every single piece of output as the one that’ll be a breakout hit.

Going back to the baseball analogy from earlier on, every time a batsman faces a pitch, they’ll see it as a home run. Everything they have will go into the next swing. And to build an audience you need to feel that same way about every piece of content you share.

You need to feel that everything you put out is excellent. Every post, every video, every image has the chance to be a hit. Without this feeling, you’re not going to break through the noise.

Quality shouldn’t be confused with perfectionism. Perfect sits in your drafts for too long. Perfect causes delays. Quality is published consistently, without lingering.

On quality vs. perfection, James Clear explains an excerpt from Art & Fear on his blog:

The ceramics teacher announced that he was dividing the class into two groups. All those on the left side of the studio, he said, would be graded solely on the quantity of work they produced, all those on the right solely on its quality.

His procedure was simple: on the final day of class he would bring in his bathroom scales and weigh the work of the “quantity” group: fifty pounds of pots rated an “A”, forty pounds a “B”, and so on. Those being graded on “quality”, however, needed to produce only one pot — albeit a perfect one — to get an “A”.

Well, grading time came and a curious fact emerged: the works of highest quality were all produced by the group being graded for quantity!

It seems that while the “quantity” group was busily churning out piles of work — and learning from their mistakes — the “quality” group had sat around theorizing about perfection, and in the end had little more to show for their efforts than grandiose theories and a pile of dead clay.

6. Be Consistent

It takes patience to build an audience, and it takes courage to keep putting yourself out there time and again.

Consistency is key, and it doesn’t come easy as Sean McCabe explains:

I think people believe that those who show up consistently have some sort of magic power or inherent ability. “It must come easy for him,” they say. “For others like me, it’s hard.”

Here’s the reality: it’s not easy for anyone — even the people who make it look easy. In fact, if someone is making it look easy, they’re probably working all the harder.

When Unbounce launched, consistency played a big role in the growth of their audience as Co-founder, Oli Gardner, penned 300 posts for the Unbounce blog over a six month period.

Consistently creating content was also critical to our early growth here at Buffer. Within Buffer’s first nine months, Leo wrote around 150 guest posts, which were vital in helping us acquire our first 100,000 sign ups.

Leo explained the importance of consistency over at Search Engine Watch: “Of course the early ones barely drove any traffic and only very gradually did things improve, I think that’s very important to understand. It will take a while until you can find the right frequency of posting.”

Another great example of the power of consistency is Youtuber, Casey Neistat.

When Neistat started daily vlogging he had around 520,000 subscribers on his YouTube Channel. Now he has over 1,500,000 subscribers.

You can see the impact his consistent, daily posts had on his subscriber growth from March — July 2015 below:

Why Building an Audience is Hard | Search Engine Journal

One of the best ways to achieve consistency is to set a schedule for yourself and stick to it. Most of us only create content when we’re hit by a moment of inspiration. But if you’re looking to build an audience, you need to be putting yourself out there regularly. 

I’ve always struggled with this one myself. But now, knowing I have to create content on a regular basis, means I can’t skip writing. Instead of sitting down and wondering which days I’ll write, I now have a schedule in place.

Over to You

Building an audience is something I’m continuously working on both personally and at Buffer. The rewards make it feel worthwhile – seeing people share your content and enjoy your work is priceless.

In a way, this post serves as a public reminder to myself that I need to be dedicated and focused every day if I want to succeed and continue to build an audience.

To summarize, here are six action points to keep in mind when it comes to building an audience:

  • Hone your skills and keep an eye on what’s next
  • Find your voice and create content in a way that only you can
  • Discover what makes you different
  • Work hard
  • Strive for quality and avoid seeking perfection
  • Be consistent and put yourself out there every day

I’d love to hear your thoughts on this too. What are your feelings about growing an audience? What have you tried? What’s worked?

Drop a note below in the comments and I’ll be excited to join the conversation.


This post originally appeared on Buffer, and is re-published with permission.

Image Credits

Featured Image: Image by Ash Read
All screenshots by Ash Read. Taken December 2015.

Ash Read

Ash Read

Content Crafter at Buffer
Content crafter at Buffer. I’m fascinated by storytelling, entrepreneurship, and travel. When I'm not writing, you'll usually find me on a football pitch or basketball... Read Full Bio
Get the latest news from Search Engine Journal!
We value your privacy! See our policy here.
  • Souleye Cisse

    this is awesome. all you saying is so awesomely true that while reading I could stop acquiescing and shaking my head at the same time. as a web marketer I’m dealing with small business owners whose lack of success lies primarily in the lack of understanding the we no longer live in a push-button world – have we ever – in which you can remote control success. or have it served as pizza delivery. I tell them that all success stories, no exceptions, are based on long, long hours of relentless, unforgiving work until you start seeing the light of day. most of the things that you put on the post, I kinda knew already but the good part is that knowing is not enough. due to our short attention span, we need to be reminded constantly. thank you for sharing and happy holidays.

    • Ash Read

      Hey Souleye! Thanks so much for reading and leaving a comment! Hope you enjoyed the holidays and wishing you a Happy New Year! 🙂

  • Ammon Johns

    I love that you started this whole piece with that wonderful and true quotation: “Nothing in the world is worth having or worth doing unless it means effort, pain, difficulty…”

    But somehow, you then immediately both ignored it, and forgot that you’d identified it, and went for Easy mode. First Mover Advantage is great, but it is a easy-mode cheat, and it is really a one-shot deal. You get to choose one platform, and being a first mover, you are expected to be a true believer and evangelist, staying with that ship until it sinks. We’ve all seen this in social media again and again too, so you can expect to be derided and have your following dismissed as mostly just being FMA.

    Yes, there will always be people who are taken in by pure follower counts, regardless of what easy-mode trick or tactic was used, right down to buying followers at a dollar a thousand. “There’s a sucker born every minute”. And if you want to be influential to suckers, if you think an audience of the gullible are what you need, go for it. But remember that they are gullible, and the next huckster in line is ready to take them in another direction.

    “Nothing in the world is worth having or worth doing unless it means effort, pain, difficulty…” which means there is more merit and more value in building your audience the hard way. Do it on an established platform. Oust and shake-up the existing hierarchy. Because doing that is how you learn how to do that. Once you know and have proven that you can shake giants on their own terms and their own turf, you are armed for anything.

    • Ash Read

      Hey there Ammon! Thanks so much for reading and leaving a comment!

      I agree that first mover advantage is a bit of a gamble – you can never guarantee which platforms will take off and which will sink after all. I feel it’s more about having the skills ready to be a first mover – for example, first movers on Snapchat could already tell stories through image and video – they didn’t need to learn a whole new skillset to gain an advantage.

      Love your point about doing it the hard way being more beneficial! 100% agree with that. Thanks again for your comment Ammon! Have an awesome New Year!

  • Siri Innovations

    If anyone follow this statistics they can easily build the audience

  • Roger Rogerson

    There are some good bits in there – but you’re missing some ingredients as well.

    Being Useful.
    Being Different.
    Going the extra mile.
    Pushing the boundaries.
    Swimming against the tide.
    Going out on a limb.
    Covering what’s missed/glossed over.
    Adding the other perspective(s).
    A pinch (or punch) of contention.
    … and many more.

    The keys there are knowledge, experience and effort.
    Look at the huge quantities of fluff, dross and general weak garbage produced en-mass … and it’s getting worse.
    People gloss over details due to laziness, inconsideration or ignorance.
    People forget to cover important points, or additional points.
    People don’t bother responding to question or comments.
    People neglect to reference names, even though those people prompted the piece or helped make it better.
    People go for the easy-route far to often.

    It’s not just a case of running up that hill as fast as you can.
    You have to run up that hill, carrying your readers and their needs, and point out the lovely scenery whilst doing so 😀

    • Ash Read

      Thanks so much for the comment Roger! So great to read your thoughts on this post 🙂

      • Roger Rogerson

        Well, I’m a prime example of “effort and thought”.
        I’m not a top-name, but I am known to some of them … and over a year amassed several thousand secondary names simply by commenting on their stuff, sharing and analysing other peoples posts … and throwing out a quick little blog.
        No major effort, no serious attempts at gaining traction … but I outperformed many who scrabbled, scrambled and tried desperately to gain ground. The main reason being people appreciated the contents of the comments/posts/shares.

        It all depends on intent and goals.
        If you are flogging something to the masses, then simple, repeated content will work if you add a little polish and base posts on volume.
        Look at people like Patel – prime example. Not seen anything “new”, and often just stuff following trends … but the masses of clueless eat it up.
        Or you can be more discerning, thoughtful, detailed … and have far fewer in your audience – but they will often be higher up the food chain.,

  • Rachael Mare

    Great post. Some people treat it like it’s no big deal … but it’s slow and hard and takes a lot of work and putting yourself out there. You have to live with a lot of uncertainty. It’s always good to hear that someone who’s super successful today spent 4 years just blogging. 🙂

  • Robert David Lang

    Thank you for this great read! Inspiring and I can read in between the lines. If you want to create the next big thing on the web, unique content will get you noticed, but creating apps or websites with unique services as a first mover advantage, is what will assure you much better returns on your time and bank accounts.

    The link to discovering your own voice was a very significant point in this article. As was the point to keep looking for trends in what people are being polarized to. A really great read as well! Many thanks!

  • Luqman Khan

    Spot on. One of the best posts about building audience that I have read to date!

    Doesn’t it all boil down make a worthwhile content strategy and sticking to it until there is a genuine need to pivot?