Knee Jerk Reactions to Google Penalties
A strong case of agita is felt when you view the nasty cliff in Analytics that once was your traffic. Instead of analyzing the cause of the discomfort, the knee jerk reaction is to scramble for a reconsideration request or submit a disavow – essentially grabbing a handful of antacid and hoping the pain goes away. In my view, the Penguin algorithm update isn’t a penalty, it’s a brutal lesson to change behaviors that Google has been long warning us about.
Without doing the hard work of link pruning and link removal, these knee jerk actions will ultimately fail and only prolong the negative effects. The disavow tool was intended to be used after a website owner or SEO has removed spammy, paid for, or otherwise illegitimate links that intended to or appeared to have the intent to game the system and not to be used without first applying maximum effort.
The rush to cut corners during the penguin recovery process verifies that the original link building strategy hasn’t been corrected and the Penguin algorithm that was applied to a website is justified. When a disavow or reconsideration request is properly paired with documents and documentation that show the depth of work performed, the website is proving to Google that they stopped, looked and listened. They accepted the problem, pulled together data, analyzed the situation, strategized how they could improve and did the painfully tedious work to rectify the situation. Ultimately, the hard work and showing how that work was performed will set a site free as it shows that former practices have been rectified.
The Details of the Disavow
If you some Googling, there are multiple shoddy disavow and reconsideration requests available for review. There are also quite a few really strong case studies on how to remove links effectively. In many of these examples, the success of a recovery effort is in the documentation.
The link removal documents should answer:
- How URLs were contacted for removal
- How many attempts were made with dates
- If the requests successful
- What additional contact methods were used
- If payment was requested for removal
- If a link originally reported as active became stripped
Additional details to consider
- Since this is Google’s game, give them some love and document every last detail using their products.
- You may have an email address that matches the domain but sync it to a Gmail account and organize the folders similar to the spreadsheets that are being used. Not only will it make your life easier, but at the end of the process you can drop your spreadsheets into an associated Google Drive and share the link in your disavow file.
- This will give depth to the disavow’s text file and offer the ability to view the complete, well documented play book of the clean up process while offering further reassurance that Penguin was taken seriously.
Disavow After Your Room’s Cleaned
Many associate penalties with being on Google’s radar. In some respects this is accurate. If Google is truly interested in giving users the best answer to their query and is able to deduce that a website is gaming their ability to judge who should compete in a SERP, surely they are going to take a deeper look around a website than they normally do with a crawl. Addressing onsite issues is hugely important with Penguin recovery as it enables additional insights into a website owner or SEO’s level remorse.
- Take the time to perform a deep site audit and correct the issues that are uncovered. Implement changes such as rel=author, rich snippets, and other adjustments that have been ignored in favor of other marketing activities.
- Update content and improve the user experience and interaction on the website.
- Verify that Webmaster Tools is clean, without any 404 or server issues and keep an updated and accurate sitemap.
- Verify social media profiles associated with the website and encourage interactions that result in a visit to your website.
Include all of these updates in your documentation to highlight the additional steps and work performed beyond the scope of Penguin. Cleaning up on-site issues won’t cure a website of its Penguin ills on its own but it will help sooth any unforeseen ruffles in the reconsideration process.
What details have given the greatest impact with your link removal and disavow process?
Image Credit: Shutterstock / fotoscool
Subscribe to SEJ
Get our daily newsletter from SEJ's Founder Loren Baker about the latest news in the industry!