Louis Liem

The New Alexa Ranking - Still Useless or Not, Reap Its Benefits Before Your Competitors Do!

April 23rd, 2008 by Louis Liem | 26 Comments

There were many critiques on the Alexa Rank, resulting in a major Alexa Rank update recently. In the past, some looked at its flaws and still, some noted its potencies. Which side ARE you on now?

What is Alexa Ranking?

The new Alexa Ranking is aimed to provide a better traffic estimation for all sites on the web. It works by collecting data (reaches and page views) from millions of Alexa Toolbar users. Those data are needed to perform a geometric mean by averaging them over a period of three months. Beside of those two measurements, the new Alexa Ranking takes in various traffic data sources as well. Where they are anonimously computed to present the traffic rankings shown as the Alexa Ranking. The three-month change is obtained by matching up the current rank with its rank from the previous three months.

  • For example, on July 1, the three-month change would show the difference between the rank based on traffic during the first quarter of the year and the rank based on traffic during the second quarter.

Reach is defined as how many unique Alexa users (people with Alexa Toolbar) visit the site. Webmasters or blog owners will see reach as a percentage of Alexa users visit their site/blog.

  • Alexa’s one-week and three-month average reach are measures of daily reach, averaged over the specified time period. The three-month change is determined by comparing a site’s current reach with its values from three months ago.

Page views represent how many pages viewed by Alexa Toolbar users. However, multiple views on the same page by the same user on the same day are counted once.

  • The page views per user numbers are the average numbers of unique pages viewed per user per day by the visitors to the site. The three-month change is determined by comparing a site’s current page view numbers with those from three months ago.

Finally, the site having the most result in the computation will be ranked number one. On the contrary, the one ranks in millions can be considered having next to nothing in traffic.

How accurate the Alexa Rank is

According to the World Internet Usage Statistics News and Population Stats, there were 1,319,872,109 Internet users around the globe on 2007. Even if the precise quantity fell below the statistic, Alexa Toolbar users only composed 10% top of the whole internet users population. Here’s from Alexa.com’s Help Section:

  • The traffic rank is based on three months of aggregated historical traffic data from millions of Alexa Toolbar users and is a combined measure of page views and users (reach).

Moreover, still 4.5% of the web surfers were using browsers unsupported by the Alexa Toolbar and the ones do (94.5% of the 10% of the internet users) and install the toolbar are mostly only webmasters and internet savvies. Most of the world’s web surfers aren’t knowledged about web rankings and traffic.

However, with the recent update that now Alexa comprises other, diverse traffic data sources in determining a site’s rank, it is expected that Alexa’s measurement will be more accurate than it was.

Another progress from Alexa is now they’re trying to make exceptions for blogs or personal home pages, if they’re able to be automatically identified from the URL. Although…

  • the Web hosts www.msn.com, carpoint.msn.com and slate.msn.com are all treated as part of the same site, because they all reside on the same domain, msn.com.

The last thing Alexa intend to fix is the bias problem for a better ranking calculation. The normalization they perform incorporates these factors:

  • the geographic location
  • the demographic distribution
  • the amount of users who might not use the toolbar

If the update didn’t come out as expected, would Alexa Rank have any good at all?

It DOES! Bigger than you think, in fact. Doesn’t care how much people say how imperfect Alexa Ranking is, there are way more who rely not only to Google’s PR to determine the value of a website and they will keep that way.

Before we go into finding out who are those people, let’s observe how you can exploit the benefits instead of being misled by its flaws.

Spy on your competitors

With the old method of Alexa Ranking, it made sense to watch for your competitors in the same industry, since the bias problem occured when analyzing your traffic stats applied also to your competitor.

Now, after Alexa released its update on the ranking process, we can still use Alexa Ranking to make a better estimation of other players in the industry. For example, if a site went down on Alexa Rank after the update (getting worse), we can tell that they have more visitors with Alexa Toolbar installed. And if a site went up in ranking, most likely they have less visitors with the toolbar installed because Alexa now counts “other factors” outside their toolbar users data. Back to the analysis, who are the people usually install the Alexa Toolbar? Webmasters are one example. So we can figure out our competitors’ readers segmentation this way.

Another advantage we have from Alexa is, the ranks contain facts that mostly invisible for public (reaches and page views). The information provided by Alexa Rank about websites is valuable that is not usually presented for free. This time, Alexa Ranking provides you an immediate view of you and your competitors’ performance comparison.

Even though Alexa hasn’t disclose where they source their “various traffic data”, we can still expect a better accuracy and comparison result from Alexa Traffic Stats.

More believers than naysayers

The other fine reason to start gaining advantages of Alexa Rank is more of your visitors are getting alerted of the Alexa Ranking. When visitors came to your site for the first time and they saw your site ranked in millions, they would think that they’re the only one visiting the site and very few else did. This can affect their thoughts that your content wasn’t so interesting and before they even scroll through your main page, they left your site. On the contrary, having a significant Alexa Rank can provide another reason for your visitors to trust your content.

Beside of your visitors, most of the advertisers and networks you plan to monetize your site with, examine you Alexa Rank before determining your site’s marketing prospective. They prefer to look at these stats since the information is usually not available publicly. So, if you’re charging a 125×125 ad space, $50/month for your #5,987,123 ranked site, advertisers won’t fall for it and it’ll be easier to sell a 10 pages ebook of “I Earn $10,000/month Pressing Keyboards” for $500.

Any other reasons?

The Alexa Rank becomes more and more regarded as a measurement of how well known a site is, so you can take an advantage of the progress by:

  • Having the Alexa Ranking supports your inclined success story.
  • Having the Alexa Ranking as your bargaining tool for getting a better advertisement offer.
  • Having the Alexa Ranking presents you and your competitors’ position in your niche/industry.
  • Having the Alexa Ranking as a “Lie Detector” of a so-called “SEO Master” with 20,000 visitors per day but ranked in #6,000,000 in Alexa’s.
  • Having the Alexa Ranking tells you that your site begins enjoying quite good traffic once your site make to the top 100,000. The reason is the more Alexa users visit your site, the lower your rank. So if you get into the top 100,000 instead of millions, it means more people visit your site and the information provided will be more accurate.

So, with all the points above, it is much less matter now what’s your judgment about Alexa Rank. If you need your visitors and you want your site to earn you well, maybe it is the time to consider reaping some benefits of Alexa Rank’s existence, before your competitors do.





Comments

26 responses so far ↓

  • Bloggeries Forum on Apr 23, 2008 at 8:42 am

    Interesting. Despite the change I still think it’s arguably the best useless metric we all have access too. Take it for what it is but until something better comes out we at least have to give them credit for trying and succeeding to some extent.

  • Louis Liem on Apr 23, 2008 at 10:16 am

    I guess we’re hoping their improvements bring them further from useless then.

  • Sushubh on Apr 23, 2008 at 11:24 am

    millions of Alexa Toolbar users…

    wow.

  • Llama Money on Apr 23, 2008 at 12:56 pm

    Accuracy aside, I think the Alexa rank is fantastic. The changes they recently made are great, unless you’re running a tech site that is!

    Part of the reason Alexa is so great, I think, is the frequency of updates. It’s not like the PR toolbar that changes whenever Google feels like it.

  • Louis Liem on Apr 23, 2008 at 9:21 pm

    Yeah, and additionally, their information detail is free and public :) .

  • bloggista on Apr 24, 2008 at 12:51 pm

    By far, the most comprehensive article on the Alexa ranking system. Great job. This one’s worthy of a digg and stumble.

  • Jason Lancaster on Apr 24, 2008 at 1:22 pm

    What about Quantcast? I quantify all my sites with a simply javascript and I enjoy the benefits of verifiable third party tracking. Since their technology uses an actual analytical tool (instead of a ridiculous “toolbar”), it’s almost impossible to game their numbers. They also offer some interesting demographic information that Alexa doesn’t provide.

    Oh yeah - it’s free too.

    I think Quantcast is probably inaccurate as well, but I doubt it’s anywhere as bad as Alexa. Alexa is a holdover from an old era. Let it go already.

  • Mr. Javo on Apr 24, 2008 at 8:05 pm

    Hey Louis, great article. Alexa is a great tool to track your traffic progress, and now with all those updates, the ranking process is more accurate.

  • Louis Liem on Apr 24, 2008 at 9:49 pm

    @Jason:
    I haven’t use Quantcast myself, but I found another point of view from Shoemoney’s and the comments on Oct 2007.

    @Javo:
    Thank you. Even Alexa have been around since most of us haven’t been online yet, I believe if they still care for updating, they do really mean business.

  • Shawn on Apr 24, 2008 at 10:43 pm

    Hey Everyone,
    Don’t forget compete.com too. I installed their bottom toolbar widget so it’s right next to Alexa in my Firefox. Sometimes their count is similar to Alexa.

    It’s also sort of nice to see which sites have been given the “green checkmark” by compete.com and which ones haven’t. I wonder if Google watches it?

  • luq on Apr 25, 2008 at 1:13 am

    one of the very few articles about alexa which is actually not entirely negative about the system..great post!

  • Syed Balkhi on Apr 25, 2008 at 5:46 am

    this is a great post. All I can say is that alexa could possibly be improving and all the manipulation techniques might not work. But only time will answer that because alexa hasn’t put out any words in public yet.

  • Roshan Bhattarai on Apr 25, 2008 at 6:16 am

    I think alexa is getting better now and trying to be accurate and collecting data from the various sources…

  • Noobpreneur on Apr 28, 2008 at 9:54 am

    Louis,

    Well said - alexa new system should be better than before - good news for most of us :)

  • Gireesh Sharma on May 1, 2008 at 6:49 am

    Even my website’s ranking dropped, though by couple of thousands only.

    http://www.empxtrack.com

    Strangely, we are seeing a consistent increase in the number of unique visitors through Statcounter.com, the changes in Alexa ranking are slightly dis-aligned.

    Wondering, how to make our visitors install Alexa Tool bar!!!

    Gireesh

  • Louis Liem on May 1, 2008 at 11:54 pm

    In my opinion, the best way is to install the toolbar ourselves and tell the visitors our experience with Alexa toolbar.

  • web and Rank on May 9, 2008 at 4:21 am

    you provide to us a very good articles,i belive the Alexa ranking will take more and more importance in the next future also to detect if one website is secure by the quantity of traffic rank.

    cheers

  • Jad on May 23, 2008 at 5:22 pm

    gr8 article :D !!

  • Robert on Jun 21, 2008 at 6:11 am

    Somehow I missed the review invite - just found it. So thanks for the update.

    For the rank and file blogger using Alexa is a great tool for an overview of where your blog stands. Accuracy is debatable and competitors such as Compete continue to arrive.

    Great write up. An article worth review.

    Cheers

  • Ari Lestariono on Nov 12, 2008 at 6:25 am

    My blog still new and has alexa rank 1,700,000 I am doing many ways to increase traffic, suppose I managed to be 100,000 can anybody tell me what kind of rough figure the visitors per day would be?and what kind of bargaining power I can use to advertisers and make good money out of it?thanks in advance

  • Louis Liem on Nov 18, 2008 at 8:37 am

    You can use forum signatures, SEO, etc. The point is to spread as many words as possible sbout your blog and have people to visit your blog.

    To get 100,000 Alexa requires 5,000 visits/month according to my Google Analytics.

  • haifafans on Dec 28, 2008 at 10:38 am

    great topic thx u

  • non-believer on Feb 5, 2009 at 10:18 pm

    Alexa Toolbar users only composed 10% top of the whole internet users population.
    ==========================
    Could somebody double check the percentage for me? I think ‘millions of Alexa Toolbar users’ would only account for less than 1% of the total Internet population, not 10%.

    Also, it is still possible to manipulate a site’s traffic ranking even after the updates. I know this because I personally did it with a company I hired in Asia.

  • Ari Lestariono on Feb 5, 2009 at 10:27 pm

    Alexa does not a direct parameter of how strong your site.If you want to get indexed pages fast on search engine, do blog comments to blogs that have PR3 and above , as many as possible.From that point you will get indexed by search engine through comments you left.For Alexa it’s the big advertiser looks and review whether your site/blog is nominated to put their banner, link or any advertising tools

  • slym on Feb 14, 2009 at 2:07 am

    This is a great post, fortunately 70% of the time of website owner is consumed in experimenting towards increasing page rank and alexa rank. To start with increasing page rank one must start with downloading Alexa toolbar for IE or firefox on as many system possible. as a second step alexa widget on every page of your website, by this way every webpage opened is counted while calculating rank inspite is user does not have alexa toolbar installed knowtheworldaround.com

  • hi on May 15, 2009 at 7:23 pm

    I have two mew blog sites on bloger.com
    with little or no traffic one has alexa of 400 with 8 hits in the last month and one has a alexa rank of 8 with less than 40 hits in the last month .any idea how this happened ?Cause i dont

Leave a Comment